As Salam Alie Kum Wa Rehmatullahi WA Barkathu,
Bismillah Hir Rehman Hir Raheem.
NOTE : I’m not asking for help or money or anything. I’m asking you to explain why this happened to me.
My brother, I have only 1 Question,
Why did my Allah abandon me?
I’m a good person, always believed in him, did everything to the best of my abilities for him as per the guidelines provided by his Massager. I was a very very pious and devout person who recited Ishraq, Chasth, Salatul Ababin, Tehjood, apart from multiple tasbi per day in his name. Never missed a day. I did my business the way his Messager told us to, with utmost honesty. Then where did I go wrong? What action of mine caused him to abandon me?
I never went movies, never went to disco, clubs, no bad habits whatsoever.
In 2001 my business started failing. Even though I paid Zakat, Sadkha, and financed 22 madrassa and mosque expenses without anyone knowing. I also used to give Zakat honestly and Sadkha weekly. I used to help poor people with business advise, medical expenses, fooding expenses etc. To the best of my ability.
In 2006 I was married to a girl who was presented as a very pious person but later turned out she used to say Namaz is for poor and sick people not for her. Being a Muslim she rejected the teachings and ultimately divorced.
Please understand I never had a girlfriend this was the first woman in my life who turned out like this. I was in acute depression for 3 years because of this. This caused my business to crash because my attention was not there.
Regardless, I went did my hajj, continued to do my duty because I used to believe that Allah had something better in store for me.
In 2013 I got married again, this woman was much much worse than the first. As previously she was presented as religious and pious but after marriage I realized it was all a lie. So I taught her Arabic to read the Quran. But she slowly started abusing me physically and emotionally. She and her mother would force me to visit their tantric for black magic but I refused because it is forbidden in Islam. Everything was money, property etc etc. She used to say if I can hurt you for one second my heart will be happy, I asked her why so, she said just like that. I used to go for Fajr prayers and she accused me of visiting prostitute. I used to help poor people she accused me of wanting to sleep with them. As Allah is my witness I’ve not done any of those things.
In 2014 when I saw situation was turning bad, I advised her to go to Umrah with me. So obviously I taught her how to preform Umrah, all hot spot for gruntee dua acceptance, what to recite, where to recite. I showed her Pic and videos on YouTube, printed out duals for Tawas etc so it was easy for her. But the moment we reached makkah and saw the holy kaaba I started crying because a nobody like me was in the holiest place in the universe. She turned to me and said stop crying you are embarrassing me. Then she said the kaaba is so small I thought it would have been bigger, why don’t they demolish it and make a bigger one. I told her once upon a time an king came with elephants and failed, I’m a nobody to even think so. That time in Umrah, 4th round, just few feet from rukh e yamni she told me to divorce her when we got back to India. And so began the horror of Umrah.
Allah is my witness, I tried to make this marriage work but it fell apart. Ultimately divorce happened. One week after divorce she filed 8 criminal case against me and my family and had me arrested and sent to jail. On charges of domestic violence to rape. In her charges she said my sisters husband wanted to sleep with her and she refused so I beat and kicked her. Allah is my witness that is not true, what man would force his wife to sleep with his sisters husband. I pleaded to court that divorce has already happened so how can it be. But she said she doesn’t recognize sharia, and that she considers herself still married. The High Court ruled in my favor that the divorce has happened and communicated and granted me bail.
In the meantime she along with some goons forcefully broke the locks of our door and entered my house. The whole incident was captured on CC TV, but police didn’t help, later I found out though sources that she was sleeping with the police office to get me arrested for 3 months before divorce and 2 months after my arrest.
Their plan was to capture me, beat me, get documents signed that I transferred my property to her and have me killed so that she would inherent everything and sell it off and I wouldn’t be able to defend because I would be dead. There were 7 attempts on my life. I had to leave the city and run away. No one came to help. After 2 years of living outside I returned to my city but am staying in separate place.
Till now she is forcefully living in my house and I’m living outside,. My business has completely crashed, I’m in debts to my nose and sometimes suicide seems quite tempting. She has tried to have me arrested twice more after I came back but failed.
I am living in constant fear of my life.
I spoke to a lot of imams and mufti asking them what happened, some said Allah tests his subjects to see what they do. Others said evil befalls us by our own actions. I find both these to be wrong. If Allah is testing me to see what I do, then how is he the, All Knowing, does he not know what I’ll do, did Allah not know Prophet will do good and Hitler will do evil. So that doesn’t make sense that Allah tested. In the second, our actions befall evil upon us is also not correct simply because I ask what evil did all our prophets do that they had to suffer such evil in their life. Their life was much much tougher than ours.
While in jail I used to think, Allah sent Prophet Yusuf to jail on false charges so am I here and Inshallah he will reward me. While I was running for my life, I used to think, Allah made the prophet run for his life from mecca. So again Allah has something in store for me.
Prophet has said, that Allah has said, do business with me, Inshallah I’m the one who’ll give you the best deal.
I did business with Allah, on his terms, but here I lay as useless as can be, a burden to earth, to Islam, to my family.
Tell me who will marry their daughter to a man who had divorced twice, no business, no source of income, jail history. Who will bear me children so I can populate Islam. In India people wear beards and caps and pretend to be Muslim but where do their Iman go, do they not realize the Hazrat Khadija was a princess who married Mohammed who was a nobody that time. Then do they not realize that fortunes are given Allah. Do they not realize that Prophet Yousuf was abandoned in a dark well to die but Allah made him king of the land. Then where does this Iman go when looking at a person who has nothing today. Do they not know that Prophet Ismail was inside a fish in darkness and Allah granted him favor. Do they not see Prophet Ibhramin was ready to sacrifice his son for Allah. Do they not see that Prophet Abraham was thrown in raging fire and the fire didn’t harm him. How many of Allah’s powers will they deny. Are they deaf, are they blind, are they of unsound mind that they cannot see Allah’s signs everywhere. Is it not possible in Allah’s power, the king of universe, the creator of life, to simply say kunfayakun, and I will be blessed with riches in future. Why do they hesitate.
I did business with Allah, I did what he asked me to do, when he asked me to do it. I did everything he told me to do. Then why did I suffer a loss in doing business with him. I lost everything. So is it not true, so who lied when he said do business with me I’ll give you best deals.
So I ask my question again, why did Allah betray me? Why did he abandon me?
So many of my Muslim friends drink wine, sleep with other women in Zina despite have wife and kids. But their wife’s are loyal to them, they have kids in schools, good business with good turnover. Whereas I do business on halal way but still I suffer.
Today I’ve stopped praying namaz, my Iman had diminished, I feel like Allah has stamped and sealed my heart. I feel nothing. Why did he betray and abandon me. Why did he throw me out of his pious people. How will I face him to be judged. Help me understand, please help me understand.
In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
As-salāmu ‘alaykum wa-rahmatullāhi wa-barakātuh.
Respected Brother – we acknowledge – based on your inquiry – that you have had a very difficult time for some years now. Your inquiry mentions substantial financial losses, the collapse of your business, deceit and deception from your spouses, several attempts on your life and more.
You’ve raised a number of issues and questions and stated that you have consulted with numerous Imams and Muftis and have not found their explanations to be sufficient.
Let’s look at the issues you raised one by one in detail:
Leaping to Conclusions:
First and foremost, let’s start with the most pressing and serious issue, and that is your statement that “sometimes suicide seems quite tempting” to escape the difficulties you are facing.
Please stop thinking that because you are facing so many difficult challenges there is nothing left in life worth living for. You are leaping to conclusions to justify that your life no longer has any worth because of the losses you sustained in your business, marital issues, etc.
Yes, there is no doubt – based on your inquiry – that you are facing substantial setbacks, but that does not mean that your life no longer has any meaning or that you’ve lost everything. Overgeneralizing losses by stating: “I’ve lost everything” makes one spiral deeper and deeper into stress and anxiety. There are many things worth living for – and the most important among them, is your faith [Imaan].
If you lost everything and gained the pleasure of Allah, what would you have lost? On the other hand, if you gained everything you ever dreamed of, but did not gain the pleasure of Allah, what would you have really gained?
We have full confidence that you know the answer to the question above. You do not know how many years are still ahead of you – and Insha-Allah you will find new opportunities by the Will of Allah. If one door closes, another opens. Be patient: “Indeed, with hardship [will be] ease.” [94:6]
“Window Of Tolerance”:
A “window of tolerance” is that state in which you feel calm and comfortable enough to deal with the problems and challenges of life. First defined in 1999, the term “window of tolerance” is now widely used in trauma therapy to understand how we respond to stress and adversity. [i]
While the phrase is relatively recent, the concept of expanding one’s “window of tolerance” to respond to a much higher degree of stress and trauma is grounded in the teachings of Islam. By adjusting our expectations [tawaqqu’aat], practicing patience [sabr], being content [qaan’i], and relying upon Allah [tawakkul], a person greatly increases his ability to tolerate the ups and downs in life and respond to stressful situations appropriately.
The benefit of expanding our “window of tolerance” is that:[a] The body becomes calm – and does not give into depression and anxiety.
[b] The mind becomes clear – and is able to ponder the best way to deal with life’s challenges.
When facing challenges in life (business, marital, etc.), the rule is not to punish and inflict harm upon yourself. Rather, since we are servants of Allah, we are ordered to be patient and to turn towards Allah. At the same time we use all permissible means to do what is beneficial but are content with whatever has been decreed for us.
As a result, the “window of tolerance” expands – meaning we are able to respond accordingly to difficulties and overcome these trials. This is because in patience, contentment and reliance upon Allah lies the tranquility and peace of the heart that is so important to a peaceful and happy life.
When you stopped praying your Salah and started harboring ill-intentions about Allah, you narrowed your “window of tolerance” instead of expanding it.
Think about how Musa (peace be upon him) arrived in Madyan and had no place to sleep, no work and no acquaintances in a new, foreign land – in addition to the fact that he was wanted by Fir’aun. What did Musa (peace be upon him) do? From the moment of his departure he harbored good intentions: “Perhaps my Lord will guide me to the sound way.” [28:22] Upon arrival, he did not become depressed. Rather, he watered the flocks for two women, then he turned towards the shade and made dua: “O My Lord, indeed I am in need of whatever good You send down upon me.” [28:24]
How To Expand Your “Window Of Tolerance”:
 Practice patience, contentment and reliance upon Allah. Focus only on the permissible means you have at your disposal to get out of debt and rebuild your life. Focus on the effort. Adjust your expectation by reminding yourself that you are a slave of Allah and that you are content with His decree. After you’ve utilized all permissible means – be content with the results, whatever they turn out to be.
“Innalillahi wainna ilaihi rajiun. Allahummajurny fi museebaty wa akhlif li khairan minha”
(Verily to Allah we belong and unto Him is our return.
O Allah, reward me for my affliction and compensate me with something better) [ii]
Here are two more relevant duas from hadith that you should supplicate with regularly:[b] اللهُمَّ صُبَّ عَلَيْنا الْخَيْرَ صَبًّا صَبًّا، وَلَا تَجْعَلْ عَيْشَنا كَدًّا كَدًّا
“Allahumma subba ‘alayna al-khayr sabban sabba wa laa taj’al ‘ayshana kaddan kadda”
(O’ Allah, pour goodness upon us and don’t make our life hard.) [iii] [c] اللهُمَّ اكْفِنا بِحَلَاْلِكَ عَنْ حَرَاْمِكَ وَ وَأَغْنِنا بِفَضْلِكَ عَمَّنْ سِوَاْكَ
“Allahumma ikfinaa bihalaalika ‘an haraamik wa aghninaa bifadhika ‘amman siwaak”
(O Allah, suffice us with that which You have made halal and
enrich us with Your grace from everyone besides You.) [iv]  Look at those who are in more suffering than you and praise Allah that you are not in their situation. Many are in far worse situations than you.
The greatest calamity for any believer is the passing away of the Prophet (salallahu alayhi wa sallam). Remember that, and Insha-Allah it will lighten your calamity. [v]
Why Do Prophets Face Trials?
You ask, “what evil did all our prophets do that they had to suffer such evil in their life?”
The Prophets (peace be upon them all) are innocent and without sin. As such, any difficulty they encounter has nothing to do whatsoever with any evil or sin – since they are sinless. Rather, the purpose of these trials is to: Increase their ranks in the hereafter.  Since they are sinless – if they were not afflicted with trials and difficulties, they would have been accused of being divine (and exalted is Allah above having any partners!). Their being afflicted with difficulties makes it clear that they are humans – albeit chosen to convey the message to mankind.  Since the Prophets (peace be upon them all) are role-models for all of us, their patience and contentment with the difficulties and tests they faced are shown to the people. This is a lesson for the rest of us so that we may take comfort and solace in the fact that the best of men endured much more than us. As a result, our own calamities become easier and lighter because of this. [vi]
Saints & Sinners
The reason why calamities come differ from person to person according to his/her rank and status with Allah.
As explained above, the Prophets (peace be upon them all) – since they are sinless – are afflicted for reasons specific to them.
For the friends of Allah [awliya], these trials are to remove both their mistakes and increase their ranks. For example, we know from an authentic hadith that a slave has a rank in the Hereafter that he cannot reach with his actions, so he is afflicted in his body, or his wealth or his offspring and then granted patience so that Allah makes him reach the rank that has been determined for him. [vii]
As for those who are sinful or have disbelief, then these calamities are because of their sins, acts of disobedience and disbelief.
Why Does Allah Test Us When He Is All-Knowing?
You have asked why does Allah test us while He is the All-Knowing. It is absolutely true that Allah knows everything a person will do, believer or disbeliever.
However, you also know that Allah is The Most Wise [al-Hakim] and every single command of His has wisdom – regardless of whether we understand that wisdom or not.
One underlying wisdom behind these tests and trials is for our own state to become apparent to us – so that we see for ourselves how we reacted and what we did in the dunya.
We will be witnesses to our own actions. For example, when things take a turn for the worse – do we forget Allah or have patience? When blessings are showered on us – do we forget Allah or thank Him for His favors? Then, on the Day of Judgment there will be no excuse for us – and we will not be able to say that had we been given the chance, we would have done this or that.
Now that is the wisdom of why these trials and tests come about – but it is our sincere advice to you not to delve into the depths of taqdir. Allah does not treat anyone unjustly. Keep this in mind and it will bring you serenity and peace of mind:
وَلَا يَظْلِمُ رَبُّكَ أَحَدًا
“…and your Lord treats no one with injustice.” [18:49]
Who Was Responsible For The Success Of Your Business?
Allah is the One who provides the sustenance [rizq]. Does a servant of Allah have any right to complain if Allah closes the door that He opened? Insha-Allah, another door will open – have faith and don’t give up.
Billions of people have never had the pleasure of owning their own business – and never will for their entire lives.
If Allah gave you that opportunity of owning your own business and then took it away, then praise Him for allowing you to have had a business in the first place. You enjoyed success and wealth for that duration – whereas many will never taste anything close to that their entire lives.
Are You A Slave Or Free?
Man is but a slave [‘abd] of Allah. The etiquette [adab] of this relationship demands that whatever a slave gets is but a gift from Allah, and everything belongs to Allah alone.
Our duty is to praise Him when He grants something, and have patience and be content when He decides in His Infinite Wisdom not to grant something. In fact, His “not giving” is also “giving” because His “not giving” is out of wisdom and what is in our best interest.
So if a business crashes, or a marriage ends despite using all permissible and available means to prevent it, then one should be patient and content with the Decree of Allah.
What Are Your Limbs Worth?
Many people don’t have the use of one or more of their limbs. Some can’t talk – others can’t walk. In fact, there are even some that can neither see, nor hear, nor talk.
If Allah has given you a sound body – you can see, hear, talk, walk – then these blessings are priceless. For how much would you sell your eye or tongue?
You have so many blessings of Allah that others don’t have. Use what Allah has given you to restart you life afresh. Take the necessary steps to get out of debt. Use all permissible means available to you to seek out new opportunities.
Stop having doubts about Allah. He has not abandoned you – but you are on the verge of abandoning yourself. Look at those who are in worse situations than you are so that you praise Allah for what you have.
Focus on the present and forget the past. Return to Allah. Make sincere repentance and start praying. Make up all past prayers and ask forgiveness for your lapses.
We make dua that Allah strengthens your faith, blesses you in your rizq, and enables you to marry a pious, loving spouse. Ameen.
And Allah Ta’āla Knows Best,
Mufti Sohail ibn Arif,
Assistant Mufti, Darul Iftaa
Checked and Approved by,
Mufti Ebrahim Desai.
[i] Siegel David J. The Developing Mind. How Relationships and the Brain Interact to Shape Who We Are. New. York: Guilford Press, 1999.
سمعتُ رسولَ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّمَ يقول: ما من عبدٍ تصيبُه مصيبةٌ فيقول : إنا لله وإنا إليه راجعون [ii]
اللهمَّ ! أْجُرْني في مصيبتي وأَخلِفْ لي خيرًا منها – إلا أجَره اللهُ في مصيبتِه . وأخْلَف له خيرًا منها . قالت : فلما تُوفِّيَ أبو سلمةَ قلتُ كما أمرني رسولُ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّمَ . فأَخلَفَ اللهُ لي خيرًا منه . رسولَ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّمَ
صحيح مسلم، الرقم ٩١٨
أنَّ جُلَيْبِيبًا كان امرءًا من الأنصارِ ، وكان يدخلُ على النِّساءِ ويتحدَّثُ إليهنَّ ، قال أبو بَرْزَةَ : قلتُ لامرأتي [iii]
اتُّقوا اللهَ لا تُدخِلْنَ عليكم جُلَيْبِيبًا ، قال : وكان النَّبيُّ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم إذا كان لأحدِهم أيِّمٌ لم يزوِّجْها حتَّى يعلمَ هل لرسولِ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم فيها حاجةٌ أم لا ، فقال رسولُ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم ذاتَ يومٍ لرجلٍ من الأنصارِ : يا فلانُ ، زوِّجْني ابنتَك ، قال : نعم : ونِعمةُ عَيْنٍ ، قال : إنِّي لست لنفسي أريدُها ، قال : فلمن ؟ قال : لجُلَيْبِيبٍ ، قال : يا رسولَ اللهِ ، حتَّى أستأمِرَ أمَّها ، فأتاها فقال : إنَّ رسولَ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم يخطُبُ ابنتَك ، قالت : نعم ، ونِعمةُ عَيْنٍ ، فزوِّجْ رسولَ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم ، قال : إنَّه ليس لنفسِه يريدُها ، قالت : فلمن ؟ قال : لجُلَيْبِيبٍ ، قالت : حَلقَى ألِجُلَيْبِيبٍ إنيه لا لعمرُ اللهِ لا نُزوِّجُ جُلَيْبِيبًا ، فلمَّا قام أبوها ليأتيَ النَّبيَّ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم ، قالت الفتاةُ من خِدرِها : من خطَبني إليكما ؟ قالا : رسولُ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم ، قالت : أترُدُّون على رسولِ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم أمرَه ، ادفعُوني إلى رسولِ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم فإنَّه لن يُضيِّعَني ، فذهب أبوها إلى رسولِ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم ، فقال : شأنَك بها فزوِّجْها جُلَيْبِيبًا ، قال إسحاقُ بنُ عبدِ اللهِ بنِ أبي طلحةَ لثابتٍ : هل تدري ما دعا لها رسولُ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم به ؟ قال : وما دعا لها به ؟ قال : اللَّهمَّ صُبَّ عليها الخيرَ صبًّا صبًّا ، ولا تجعلْ عيشَها كَدًّا كَدًّا ، قال ثابتٌ : فزوَّجها إيَّاه ، قال : فبينما رسولُ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم في غزاةٍ له فأفاء اللهُ عليه ، فقال : هل تفقِدون من أحدٍ ؟ قالوا : نفقِدُ فلانًا وفلانًا ونفقِدُ فلانًا ، ثمَّ قال : هل تفقِدون من أحدٍ ؟ قالوا : لا . قال : لكنِّي أفقِدُ جُلّيْبِيبًا ، فاطلبوه في القتلَى ، فنظروا في القتلَى فوجدوه إلى جنبِ سبعةٍ قد قتلهم ، ثمَّ قتلوه ، فقال رسولُ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم : قتل سبعةً ثمَّ قتلوه ، هذا منِّي وأنا منه ، يقولُها مِرارًا ، فوضعه رسولُ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم على ساعدِه ما له سريرٌ إلَّا ساعدَيْ رسولِ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم حتَّى وضعه في قبرِه ، قال ثابتٌ : فما كان من الأنصارِ أيِّمٌ أنفقَ منها
شعب الإيمان ٢/ ٦٧٢ خلاصة حكم المحدث : أخرجه مسلم آخر هذا الحديث ، عن إسحاق بن عمر بن سليط ، عن حماد والجميع صحيح على شرطه
عن علِيٍّ أن مكاتَبًا جاءَهُ فقال إِنَّي قد عجزْتُ عن كِتابتي فأعِنِّي قال ألَا أُعَلِّمُكَ كلماتٍ علَّمَنِيهِنَّ رسولُ اللهِ [iv]
صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّمَ لو كانَ عليكَ مثلَ جبلِ صِيرٍ دَيْنًا أدَّاهُ اللهُ عنكَ قال قلْ اللهمَّ اكفِنِي بحلالِكَ عن حرَامِكَ وأغْنِنِي بفَضْلِكَ عن سواكَ
سنن الترمذي الرقم: ٣٥٦٣ خلاصة حكم المحدث: هذا حديث حسن غريب
من أصيب بمصيبة فليذكر مصيبته بي فإنها من أعظم المصائب [v]
الجامع لشعب الإيمان، ١٢/ ٤٢٤ الرقم: ٩٦٧٨
قال المحقق مختار أحمد الندوي: إسناده ضعيف والحديث حسن بشواهده
قال الحافظ ابن حجر في ” الإصابة ” ٢/٢: إسناده حسن لكن اختلف فيه على علقمة
ولأنهم لو لم يبتلوا لتوهم فيهم الألوهية، وليتوهن على الأمة الصبر على البلية [vi]
مرقاة المفاتيح، ٤/ ٣٥
إنَّ العبدَ إذا سبقت له من اللهِ منزلةٌ لم يبلغْها بعمله ابتلاه اللهُ في جسدِه أو في مالِه أو في ولدِه ثم صبَّره على [vii]
ذلك حتى يُبلِّغَه المنزلةَ التي سبقت له من اللهِ تعالى.
سنن أبي داود، الرقم ٣٠٩٠