Home | Fatwa | Two persons slaughtering each other’s Qurbani animal in error

Two persons slaughtering each other’s Qurbani animal in error


Nasihah (Advice): The starting time of Qurbani


Sayyiduna Anas Bin Maalik Radhiyallahu Anhu reports that Nabi Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam said: “Whoever slaughtered an (Qurbani) animal before the Salaah (of Eid), he has slaughtered it for himself; and whoever slaughtered it after the Salaah (of Eid); he has completed his ritual and has followed the tradition of the Muslims.” (Bukhari)




Question and Answer:


  1. Last year, my uncle and I bought sheep from a farmer for Eid. My sheep and my uncles sheep were marked slightly differently from each other to show which sheep belongs to who. On Eid day, my uncle slaughtered my sheep thinking it is his and I slaughtered my uncles sheep thinking it is mines. Are both of our Qurbani’s valid for last year?



  1. In the enquired case of your uncle slaughtering your Qurbani animal and you slaughtering his animal, the Qurbani of your uncle and yourself will be valid. It would be regarded as both of you slaughtering the animals on each other’s behalf. (Al-Muheetul-Burhani 5/479)


And Allah Ta’ala Knows Best



Mufti Ebrahim Desai


(Islamic rulings on this Q&A newsletter are answered in accordance to the Hanafi Fiqh) 


Fatwa Department
Jamiatul Ulama (KZN) 

Council of Muslim Theologians
223 Alpine Road, Overport

Durban, South Africa
Tel : +27 (0) 31 2077099
Fax : +27(0) 31 2074163
Website : www.jamiat.org.za


Check Also

Virtue of Praying Four Rakahs (Salatud Duha) in The Morning

Question Regarding the following Hadith, what is meant by “suffice”? Does it mean that Allah …

Hadith: Whoever Gives me The Good News Of Safar Departing/Commencing

 http://hadithanswers.com Question I need to know if this Hadith is authentic: Anyone who gives me …